MusicalMahem's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Hallelujah performed by Cayler]

Brought me to tears...

This is my favourite song and you my friend have definitely brought tears to my eyes. To me this song has so much value behind it (most likely not like others) and the fact that you have pulled on my heart strings just makes this song have so much more value to it. You would sound beautiful if you were to play this live. You're version is so powerful and very much so breath taking. I would love to hear you live. If you sound fantastic now, who knows how great you would be. I could only make an assumption and any amount i were to spend to watch your performance would be worth it.

I can only imagine what it would be like... thank you for keeping such a powerful song alive and kicking.

Cayler responds:

Thanks for the great review. I'm really happy to have brought more attention to this great song that has been around for a while. And I'm glad to have pulled your heart strings :)

[Landslide- Cayler]

I don't have any words...

I've heard this song several times and never actually heard any appreciative versions of this one other than the original. You have taken a familiar song and made it your own and it's simply phenomenal. There's no words that can truly express what you have done with this song. Your voice is soothing and matches what you play giving this a very distinct heart. It stands out and will never blend in. Very beautiful. almost pine tingling (in a good way :D).

Cayler responds:

Thank you for your positive comments. :D

[December]

Wow... *Jaw dropping*

When I saw the name of the song i was really expecting something very ... depressing? But with this song you seem to bring out many emotions and the combination is beautiful. I'm not too sure what the name of the drum thing but for now i'll just call it a cymbal. Anyway, in the end it seemed too loud and that was the only i could really hear for a couple of seconds. 4:55 to about 5:10 i think.. it may seem off. Just tone the cymbals down a little so that it creates a harmony with the other intruments instead of it "Hogging the Spot Light". :D

[tree dots]

Simple Marvelous! But....

I really like how you did the crescendos and diminuendos were simple beautiful and stunning and the note choices you have made and the rhythm and beat was simply awe insipiring. The only thing i can say was very unpleasent to the ears was the very beginning with the chords. It was very abrupt and sound quite random almost like a small child learning chords for the first time. The second chord, I believe it was, caused me to write the unpleasentries of your work. It seem to not match the rest of the song. I'm so sorry if it seems very rude of me. Other than that slight critiscism the song was, as said previously, beautiful.

paravindskey responds:

Heh they weren't random for sure some people like those dissonances some not thanks for your opinion.